Atlanta Financial Blog

Are Emotions Ruling Your Portfolio?

Are Emotions Ruling Your Portfolio?

Harrison Fant, CFP®, AIF®
March 26, 2019

As human beings we may not be wired to make good financial decisions. Behavioral finance points to anchoring bias and recency bias are just two of the many factors that influence our decision-making. If not properly addressed, these biases can have a negative impact on the foundation and long-term success of your financial plan, and they tend to present themselves most strongly at the tail-end of a bull market.

Anchoring bias is the tendency to use first impressions to form perceptions, which then tend to affect our later decisions. A common example of this anchoring effect for investors is that if you buy a stock for $100 and it later drops to $80, you are predisposed to still internally value it at $100. Investors tend to anchor the fair value of their positions to the original price they paid rather than what the market tells them the investment is worth. This can result in holding losing positions for far too long in hopes that they will return to their original price, even if they never do.

The other side of this anchoring bias in investing is a disposition effect. In this case, investors are still anchored to the initial purchase price of an investment and therefore feel more comfortable selling when they can realize gains, even if selling is not advisable at that time. When anchoring and disposition biases come together, it is easy to wind up with a portfolio full of poor investments, as we’ve felt inclined to sell our winners and hold onto our losers.

Recency bias is the belief that whatever happened in the recent past is going to happen in the future. This thought process is particularly dangerous in the last few years of a bull market, as many investors believe that the sky is the limit and markets are bound to continue moving upward. We are now in the longest bull market in US history, and it is not a coincidence that many investors are flocking to index funds in hopes of matching the return of the S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq or whatever other index they feel is going to lead the charge.

Because the recent focus has been on how well these indices have performed over the last few years, many people tend to discount or completely forget about the negative volatility associated with these passive strategies. A critical detail that is often overlooked by individual investors is how their favorite index has performed over a full market cycle – from peak to peak or trough to trough. By taking a longer-term perspective you can not only be more prepared for the inevitable ups and downs of the markets, but can also cut out some of the excessive volatility from an overly-concentrated portfolio.

The question remains: How do you overcome behavioral biases that can negatively impact your portfolio and planning? The short answer is research, and a lot of it. Even with the most disciplined research approach though, it is also important to work with an objective financial professional who can help eliminate emotional decision making. These biases are just one reason why Atlanta Financial has such a uniquely robust and disciplined investment research process. All of us are wired to make decisions based on our emotions, which is why we at Atlanta Financial believe one of our main responsibilities as financial advisors is to help guide our clients to think more rationally and objectively about investing.

Share This:

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on google

And the Best Place to Retire is….!

Recently, I ran across an article about the best (and worst) states for retirement.  It caught my attention because the “best” state turned out to be ….  Nebraska!  Many would be surprised at this.  After all, who would retire in such a cold place in the middle of the country?  Actually, I was not at all surprised.  I was born in Lincoln, Nebraska and spent the first twelve years of my life there.  I still visit relatives in the Cornhusker state and enjoy the wonderful people, slower pace and beautiful scenery the state has to offer.

Read More »

We Welcome Connolly Crowley with Lots of Love!

We are excited to announce Connolly Elizabeth Crowley, daughter of Charles and Erin Crowley, was born on June 21, 2019! Weighing in at 7lbs.,15oz., Connolly makes Charles and Erin the parents of two beautiful children; Connolly is Charles and Erin’s second child…

Read More »

Is a Health Savings Account (HSA) Right for Me?

At AFA, we hear our clients express concerns about two financial challenges more often than any others:
• Will I be ready to retire with the lifestyle I want?
• What can I do to protect myself from rising health care costs now and in the future?

Did you realize there is a single vehicle that can help you make progress in both areas? It’s called a health savings account (HSA), which is a government-regulated savings account that combines many of the tax benefits of a Flexible Spending Account and a 401(k), including:
• Your contributions to the plan are pre-tax (if offered through your employer) or tax-deductible (if established on your own). If funded through your employer’s plan, you also don’t pay FICA on the contributions, putting an extra 7.65% back in your pocket.
• Withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free (more about that below).
• The balance in your plan (that you don’t spend for medical expenses) grows tax-deferred and can be rolled over from year to year, supplementing other retirement savings.

Read More »